75 Easter Basket Fillers that are NOT Candy

If you don’t want to load your kids up with sugar this year, what should you put in their Easter baskets? Here are 75 Easter Basket fillers that are NOT Candy!

Easter Baskets are a fun tradition to look forward to as we celebrate the resurrection of Christ. I’m not a big fan of of sugar, so I like to fill our Easter baskets with other things.  Hopefully some of these ideas will inspire you to do the same!

*Post contains affiliate links, please see my disclosures page for more details.

All of these items are from Amazon, and if you have Amazon PRIME, order what you need and you should get most of these in two days or less!  If not, I highly recommend you sign up NOW, it will pay for itself many times over in free shipping perks, tv shows, movies and free music.

Babies & Toddlers Easter Basket Fillers

1. Playdoh
2. Bubbles
3. Large Washable Crayons
4. Child Size Wrap Highly Protective UV Sunglasses 
5. Playful Socks
6. Keepsake Coloring Book
7. Plush Lamb that sings “Jesus Loves Me”
8. Slinkies
9. Temporary Tattoos
10. The Three Trees Board book 
11. Fun Utensils
12. Leak Proof BPA Free Sippy Cups

Children’s Easter Basket Filler Ideas

13. Melissa & Doug Harmonica
14. Velcro Ball & Catch Game
15. Stickers for BOYS, or Stickers for GIRLS
16. Presidents of the US Pez Dispensers
17. Frozen Duck Tape or Moustache Duck Tape
18. Duncan  yo-yo
19. Cross & Infinity necklace
20. Fake Snakes
21. Googly Eyes
22. Glow In the Dark Easter Eggs “Egglos”
23. Egglo Treasure Scripture Rolls
24. Lip Smackers Lip Balm
25. Nail Polish
26. Veggie Tales Easter DVD
27. Rubber Stamps
28. Hotwheels or Matchbox Cars
29. Rainbow Loom Bands
30. Earbuds or Headphones
31. Modeling Clay
32. Lego Kits
33. Fancy Pens
34. Glow in the dark stars
35. Resurrection Eggs
36. Sugar Free – Natural Gum
37. Stickers Earrings
38. Spot It Road Game
39. Small Stuffed Animals
40. Stencils
41. Slipper socks
42. Mr. Sketch Scented Markers
43. Pocket Journals
44. Six Pack of Silly putty
45. Mini Rubix Cubes
46. Colored Pencils
47. LED Light Up Shoelaces
48. Paint Brushes
49. Mini Sketch Pads
50. Watercolor paints
51. Origami Washi paper
52. Magnifying Glass
53. Pocket Watch Compass
54. Whoopie Cushions

Teen Easter Basket Filler Ideas

55. Stereo Headphones
56. Flash drive
57. Print at home – Amazon Gift Cards!
58. Would You Rather Pocket Game
59. A great book
60. Cell phone blocker
61. Mother Daughter Journal
62. Beef jerky
63. Swiss Multi Tool Key Ring
64. Bath or Shower Poufs
65. New pens
66. Washi Tape
67. Luxurious Hand Cream
68. Nail polish
69. Manicure Set
70. Zebra Lanyard
71. Tire Pressure Gauge
72. Wallet
73. Ped Egg 
74. Book Light
75. Hand Sanitizer

Be SURE to check out Amazon for more ideas to finish up shopping for everyone on your list!